
(Image sourced from Google.)
Like many American lawyers, I count Harper Lee’s novel To Kill a Mockingbird as one of my prime inspirations in joining the legal world, and the novel’s hero, Atticus Finch, as one of my great professional heroes (yes, I know he’s fictional, and no, I don’t care). I first read To Kill a Mockingbird the summer before my freshman year in high school, and I was staggered by it. I knew about my country’s shameful history of racial injustice, but To Kill a Mockingbird brought it home to me like nothing else. There are many characters in the novel, and many converging storylines, but it was Atticus and his brave defense of a man on whom the justice system had turned its back that spoke to me most. I’ve read the book countless times since. I still have my tattered paperback copy from that summer before starting high school. It’ll always be one of my favorite books. And like many readers, I always wished Harper Lee had written more.
Well. Unless you’ve been living under a rock, you’ve probably heard the big literary news. Harper Lee did write more. Her first novel, Go Set a Watchman, has just been rediscovered – and for the one or two people who haven’t already read the synopsis, it focuses on Scout as an adult woman, coming home to Maycomb to visit her father in the 1950s, and witnessing events there. Lee wrote Go Set a Watchman before writing To Kill a Mockingbird. As the story goes, the book contained some flashbacks to Scout’s childhood that Lee’s editor thought were particularly good, so he encouraged her to turn those into a book. To Kill a Mockingbird was born, and Go Set a Watchman was forgotten.
Until now, that is. What we’ve been told is that Lee’s lawyer, Tonja Carter, found Watchman stapled to the back of a Mockingbird manuscript. Lee believed Watchman to have been long since lost, and is allegedly “delighted” that it has turned up and is being published. And published with a vengeance – Harper Collins is apparently planning a first printing of two million copies. Two million. On a first printing. Basically, they’re expecting everyone and their dog to buy this book, and they’ll most likely be proven right. Which leads me to my question:
Are you going to buy Go Set a Watchman?
Since I heard the news, my feelings on the subject have waffled even more than they usually do. (And that’s saying something. I’m a champion waffler.) At first, I was elated. NEW HARPER LEE NOVEL! WHAT WHAT WHAT WHAT WHAT! Basically, my head exploded with the rest of the bookish internet. Is it July yet?
And then. And then. I read some of the thoughtful pieces, written by people more deliberative than I, laying out some very real concerns about the story we’re all being fed. First, Book Riot posted “Uncollected Thoughts on the New Harper Lee Novel,” in which Jeff O’Neal described some of the issues surrounding the release, including:
On a scale of 1 to 10 with 1 being Lee’s full-throated 100% attributable consent and 10 being the shadiest of shady dealings on behalf of the people around her, I give it a…..dammit. I wish I could give a vigorous defense of this or a heartfelt attack. I just don’t know what we are dealing with. Is the story we are being given possible? Absolutely. Is it weird that Alice Lee recently died and that Harper herself has actively avoided public life for 50 years? More than weird. Whatever the truth is, I think it is probably beyond our understanding and that there is much more going on than either a worst case or a best case scenario. If you want to go into reading this book, and reading about this book even, with your eyes open, you are probably going to have to get used to the idea that you don’t know what the truth is.
There’s a lot more there, so go read the full post. Since Book Riot’s post expressing concerns – concerns which many in the literary world share – new statements have come out purporting to be from Lee herself, affirming her approval of the project and her delight in the rediscovery of a manuscript that hasn’t seen the light of day in more than half a century, and her hurt at having to defend her competency to authorize publication of her first work. So now, the question is, can we believe that these statements are really coming from Lee herself? Or are they coming from others around her – namely, attorney Tonja Carter, who is apparently the only person involved in this process with direct access to Lee? As I knew she would, my friend Amal had plenty to say on the subject:
Is Carter committing elder abuse, which is defined under Alabama law as “the maltreatment of an older person, age 60 or above”? It includes material exploitation: “The unauthorized use of funds or any resources of an elderly individual or the misuse of power of attorney or representative payee status for one’s own advantage or profit. Examples include stealing jewelry or other property and obtaining the elderly person’s signature for transfer of property or for a will through duress or coercion.” Code of Ala. § 38-9D-2 (2014).
Again, I encourage you to go read Amal’s entire post, and her other posts on Harper Lee and To Kill a Mockingbird. (Amal is also an attorney and also a big Lee fan.) Amal’s blog has a collection of some of the best thought-out posts I’ve ever read about Harper Lee and the legal controversies surrounding her in recent years. And to be honest, as soon as I heard of some of the questions concerning Lee’s true feelings on the publication of Go Set a Watchman, one of my first questions was, I wonder what Amal thinks about this?
Amal has said that she won’t be buying a copy of Go Set a Watchman until she’s comfortably confident that her favorite author is not being taken advantage of. And she has a point. The entire situation smells funny. Is it elder abuse? I certainly hope not, but as Jeff O’Neal points out in Book Riot’s post, we might never really know. And Harper Collins certainly doesn’t expect that people will be put off by the uncertainty of the situation – not if they’re ordering a two million copy initial printing. The publisher is clearly banking on the buzz and the fact that it’s a new novel by Harper Freaking Lee. This book could be nothing but a list of names and people would buy it.
As for me? I don’t know. I started out leaping around my house (as much as I can leap around in my third trimester) and chewing hubby’s ear off about how excited I am about this book and now… now I just feel squicky about the whole thing. (That’s right, squicky. It’s an industry term.) I really, really don’t want to support any endeavor that takes advantage of anyone’s age or declining health, maybe least of all that of the woman who wrote the Great American Novel. (Yep, it’s been written already.) But… dang. I have to know what’s in this book. So now I just don’t know what to do. Am I going to buy Go Set a Watchman? If I’m being completely honest, I have to say… I probably am. I really, really respect Amal’s scruples, and the scruples of anyone else who can resist buying this book until they have a comfort level that Lee really is delighted with the whole thing. And part of me worries that if I don’t take a stand against the publication (at least until we have some clearly unbiased information about Lee’s approval) I’m part of the problem. But I don’t know that I’m strong enough to stay away from this book – especially if, as Jeff suggests, we might have to make peace with never knowing for sure. Gah. I sure wish these issues were simple. But as Atticus Finch could attest, they never are.
What about you? Are you going to buy/read Go Set a Watchman? How conflicted are you about the whole situation?


































Brainiest – This year’s Valedictorian is The Monuments Men: Allied Heroes, Nazi Thieves, and the Greatest Treasure Hunt in History, for shedding light on an aspect of World War II history of which I was completely unaware. I was hooked from the first page, and I learned a lot.
Best Looking – With the whimsical illustrations and the gorgeous reprints of letters handwritten by J.R.R. Tolkein himself, Letters from Father Christmas is a shoo-in for this one. Tolkien’s children were lucky indeed, to get these beautiful missives every Christmas.
Best Friends – I wish I could have lived at Patty’s Place with Anne, Priscilla, Stella and Phil during their years at Redmond College. Whenever I need a dose of cozy girlfriend chatter, I know I can find it between the pages of L.M. Montgomery’s Anne of the Island.
Class Clown – This would have to be The Honest Toddler: A Child’s Guide to Parenting, written under the supervision of Bunmi Laditan. I’m a huge fan of HT (as anyone who follows me on Twitter will be sure to know – sorry for all the retweets, but I can’t help myself!) and here my second-favorite toddler has written a parenting guide full of LOLs. I was rolling on the floor as I read it.
Biggest Jock – Train Like a Mother: How to Get Across Any Finish Line – And Not Lose Your Family, Job, or Sanity, by Dimity McDowell and Sarah Bowen Shea, is my pick for biggest jock. I can always count on SBS and Dimity for a dose of motherly encouragement in running, parenting and life. I bought their second Another Mother Runner book in hopes that they’d get me across the finish line of my first marathon. Pregnancy intervened, but I’ll be looking to my favorite #motherrunner duo for plenty of inspiration in 2015.
Teacher’s Pet – Hmmmm, this was a tough category to award this year. I usually have quite a few books in school settings, but not for 2014. So, the superlative goes to Laura Ingalls Wilder, circa These Happy Golden Years, in which Laura tries her hand at teaching to help support her family and save money for her sister Mary to go away to a college for the blind. Teaching is not Laura’s passion, to say the least, but she does her best, and for that she’s Teacher’s Pet this year.
Biggest Nerd – This year’s award goes to a book nerd – a lady after my own heart! Rebecca Mead’s My Life in Middlemarch will speak to any bookworm who has read her way through the same favorite classic, to the point where it becomes part of her life story. (That’d be Jane Eyre for me, but I certainly know what Mead is talking about.)
Most Creative – I read a lot of creative books this year, but The Golem and the Jinni, by Helene Wecker, takes the prize. Wecker merges two cultural traditions, and two mythical beings, into a rich tapestry of a story in which 1890s New York City is another living, breathing character. I hung on every word and didn’t want the book to end, ever.
Most Likely to End Up in Hollywood – Let me preface this by saying that if this book does end up in Hollywood, I won’t be going to see the movie. I’m not a horror fan in general, and while I did frantically turn pages to see what would happen in M.R. Carey’s The Girl With All the Gifts, and while I think it would make an incredibly gripping movie… it’s just way too scary for me!
Biggest Rebel – Is there a rebel more rebellious than Flavia de Luce? I read four of her adventures this year – A Red Herring Without Mustard, I am Half Sick of Shadows, Speaking from Among the Bones, and The Dead in their Vaulted Arches – and loved every moment of watching my favorite diabolical chemist break all the rules, solve murders and torment her two obnoxious older sisters.
Biggest Loner – Amy Gallup, from Jincy Willet’s The Writing Class and Amy Falls Down, wins this category, hands-down. All Amy wants is to hole up in her house with her resentful Basset hound, Alphonse, and write her blog “GO AWAY.” But the outside world keeps intruding on Amy – first in the form of a murderous writing student, and then later in the form of unexpected career success. What’s a washed-up recluse to do? (Read these books, please. They’re terrific!)
Most Likely to Succeed – Marcus Samuelsson is a true success story, as his memoir Yes, Chef perfectly illustrates. Born into poverty in Ethiopia and adopted, along with his sister, by a Swedish family, Marcus cultivates a love for cooking and follows his passion all the way to the top rung of the foodie career ladder – winning “Top Chef,” cooking for President Obama, and opening his own restaurant in Harlem. He doesn’t gloss over his mistakes and failures, but you’ll cheer for him all the way.