Ask me what kind of books I prefer to read, and I’ll tell you in no uncertain terms: I prefer historical classics, especially English literature, new literary fiction and travel memoirs. Ask me what books I have no interest in, and I’ll be equally emphatic: bodice-ripping romances and graphic novels hold zero appeal for me. Ask me about other genres and I might waffle a bit more.
There are two genres in particular that I’m equivocal about: dystopia and fantasy. Sure, I’ll tell you that I don’t particularly care for them, and that’s true. I’ll tell you that they won’t be my first choice, and that’s also true. But I’d be stretching the truth if I said there was nothing in either genre that I have read and liked.
Take dystopia, for instance. The plots always intrigue me, but then when I finish the books I often feel disappointed for some unidentifiable reason. Perhaps I’m just not at home in a post-apocalyptic world? Still, I have read and liked certain dystopic novels. For instance, The Handmaid’s Tale, by Margaret Atwood, was disturbing but engaging at the same time. When I closed the book, I wished I had checked it out of the library because I never wanted to look at it again, but lately I’ve been contemplating a re-read. It’s not topping the list at the moment – too many things that I haven’t yet read and want to get to first – but I think I may like it more on a second go-round. And that’s not to say I didn’t like it the first time; it was very good and I was glued to the book. But giving it time to settle definitely improved my outlook on the book and made me more willing to re-read it in the future.
Oh, and then there’s The Hunger Games trilogy. Young adult… and dystopia… two things that I generally don’t go for. But I absolutely couldn’t put the books down. I was obsessed, obsessed to a degree I haven’t experienced since the end of the Age of Potter. I talked my bestie R into reading them because I needed someone to screech at when the first movie trailer came out, and I wanted a foil for “Gale vs. Peeta” debates. (She was Team Gale, I was Team Peeta.) Despite not being a dystopia kind of girl, I literally cannot get enough Hunger Games. (Nor can R, now – she might be more obsessed than me. I created a monster.) I could talk all day about the many fascinating messages crammed into these insanely exciting books… but I’ll let you read and discover for yourself.
Then there’s fantasy. Again, not something I’m typically attracted to. Oh, I read The Mists of Avalon in high school, sure. But it’s generally just not something I “go for.” I haven’t even read The Lord of the Rings and its progeny. (I plan to, but they never seem to cycle to the top of my list. I’ll get to them, though, I swear.) But there are some fantasy books that I’ve read that made me stop and think, maybe I should give this genre a fair shake. For instance, I recently discovered Lev Grossman’s Magicians trilogy. I liked the first book, The Magicians – I wasn’t completely sold, but I did find it amusing, particularly when the characters made fun of Harry Potter. But the second book, The Magician King, absolutely blew me away and I’m now anxiously awaiting the final installment. The Magicians trilogy spoofs on The Chronicles of Narnia, which I’ve read many, many times and loved – but I find it hard to consider Narnia fantasy. To me, Narnia is a classic and a stand-alone masterpiece.
And I guess I can’t claim to be “not a fantasy reader” given my boundless levels of Harry Potter dorkdom. My Pottermania affliction is widely known. I’ve dressed up as a member of the Gryffindor Quidditch team (Alicia Spinnet, to be exact – and now you know just what a nerd I am) for a midnight release party. I just can’t help it. The Harry Potter books have everything I look for – great characters, humor, an exciting and engaging plot, and good writing (okay, I realize opinions differ on that last point, but I think Rowling’s writing is very good, especially later on in the series). I can’t help it. I just love to dive into the world of Hogwarts. Now, imagine if I never pushed myself outside of my comedy-of-manners comfort zone! I’d never have found Harry, Ron and Hermione. And I shudder to think just how boring life would be without those three.
What is your literary comfort zone, and have you ever read and loved a book that pushed you outside of it? Any dystopia or fantasy novels you’d recommend to me?


























